Beatles Mashup By Harry Nilsson

In 1967, Harry Nilsson released an album called Pandemonium Shadow Show that had a unique Beatles cover song. It is a special mix containing segments of numerous Beatles songs. It is thought to be the first mashup ever made. The Beatles Mashup by Harry Nilsson is called “You Can’t Do That.“

Although other songs may have combined more than one song before this mix, there are references to over twenty Beatles songs. So, it was ahead of it’s time as far as mashups are concerned. Indeed, the Beatles “Love” album also contains mashup songs, and that album is worth possessing.

On this Nilsson track, the primary song is a slow version of The Beatles’ “You Can’t Do That.” However, this song is a clever medley that creatively combines lyrics and musical elements from Lennon-McCartney songs. Here’s an overview of the key aspects of The Beatles Mashup by Harry Nilsson:

Overview and Composition

• Artist: Harry Nilsson
• Album: Pandemonium Shadow Show (1967)
• Genre of “You Can’t Do That”: Pop/Rock/psychedelia
• Song Type In Question: Medley/Cover
• Producer: Rick Jarrard
• Arrangement: George Tipton
• Label: RCA Victor

Beatles Mashup By Harry Nilsson: Structure and Content

“You Can’t Do That” is unique because it not only covers the Beatles’ song “You Can’t Do That” but also interweaves snippets and lyrical references from other Beatles songs. The following list shows what you should expect to hear directly or vaguely within the medley:

Obvious References (In Order)

1. “She’s a Woman“ – Starts the medley.
2. “I’m Down“ – Second song.
3. “Drive My Car“ – Lyrics and elements are woven into the medley.
4. “You Can’t Do That” – The main framework of the medley.
5. “You’re Going to Lose That Girl“ – Included in the mix.
6. “Good Day Sunshine“ – Contributes to the medley.
7. “A Hard Day’s Night“ – Referenced through lyrics and musical motifs.
8. “Rain“ – Long backing vocal.
9. “I Want to Hold Your Hand“ – Referenced lyrically and musically.
10. “Good day Sunshine“ – Contributes to the medley.
11. “Day Tripper“ – Features parts of the song.
12. “Paperback Writer“ – an obvious bit in the middle.
13. “Do You Want To Know A Secret“ – Backing singers.
14. “Yesterday“ – Features elements of this classic.
15. “Strawberry Fields Forever“ – ends the medley, but they sing “Strawberry Beatles Forever“.

Not So Obvious (Oblique References)

1. “Baby It’s You“ – Sha La La bit
2. “She Loves You“ – “Yeah”.
3. “Help!“ – Ooooh!
4. “All My Loving“ – Slender reference.
5. “Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown)“ – A slight element of this song.
6. “Ticket to Ride“ – musical phrases.
7. “I Feel Fine“ – features a hint of this song.
8. “Michelle“ – Listen closely for a reference.
9. “Girl“ – Contributions.
10. “We Can Work It Out“ – Part of the mix.
11. “Yellow Submarine“ – A subtle hint.
12. “Eleanor Rigby“ – Motifs are woven in.
13. “Can’t Buy Me Love“ – Included in the medley, but you’ll need to listen very carefully for this bit.

Nilsson’s medley demonstrates his deep appreciation and understanding of the Beatles’ music while skilfully integrating these references into a cohesive and innovative homage.

Creative Approach

Nilsson’s approach to this medley is both a tribute and a playful reimagining of the Beatles’ work. Furthermore, he seamlessly integrates various Beatles lyrics and melodies into the primary framework of “You Can’t Do That,” showcasing his admiration for the band and his innovative musical style.

Beatles Mashup By Harry Nilsson: Impact and Legacy

While “You Can’t Do That” did not become a major hit, it garnered attention for Nilsson’s inventive homage to the Beatles. Indeed, it helped establish Nilsson as a unique and creative artist capable of blending humour, innovation, and musicianship.

• Critical Acclaim: Critics praised Nilsson for his cleverness and the intricate way he wove the Beatles’ songs together.
• Influence: This song contributed to Nilsson’s reputation as a gifted songwriter and arranger. Thus, leading to greater recognition and success in his subsequent work.
• The Beatles’ Reaction: Members of the Beatles were reportedly impressed by Nilsson’s work. John Lennon and Paul McCartney, in particular, became fans of Nilsson’s music, which helped further Nilsson’s career in the late 1960s and 1970s.

Additional Notes

• Cultural Influence: Nilsson’s blending of different Beatles tracks in “You Can’t Do That” set a precedent for future artists who would engage in similar creative mash-ups and medleys.
• Musical Style: The song showcases Nilsson’s smooth vocal style. It also shows his ability to navigate complex musical arrangements with ease.

Of course, “You Can’t Do That” remains a testament to Harry Nilsson’s talent and his deep appreciation for the Beatles. Not only that, but it highlights his knack for innovation and musical homage.

Take A Listen To “The Beatles Mashup By Harry Nilsson.”

Finally, here is the song that holds references to so many Beatles classics. Some of the references obviously stick out like a sore thumb. However, some may just be a note or two cleverly entwined within the track.

We have a comprehensive list above, but if you think you can hear an extra one, tell us at which point in the song you can hear it.

Once you listen to this song, let us know your thoughts and opinions below. Also, if you like the thought of finding hidden songs, take a look at our other favourite, “Song Titles And Clues In Free As A Bird.”